Watch out for a hoax when considering unconventional medical treatments

James Metz, MD
Abramson Cancer Center of the University of Pennsylvania
Last Modified: November 1, 2001

Unconventional medical treatments for cancer are gaining increasing exposure to the public though television, the Internet, and magazines. Some unconventional therapies may one day prove to help cancer patients. These therapies are classified as 'alternative' or'unconventional' because they have not been proven to benefit cancer patientsin controlled clinical trials. It is a challenge to differentiate those techniques that offer promise from those that are hoaxes.

Many individuals claim that natural products are better to combat cancer than conventional treatments such as chemotherapy, radiation therapy, and surgery. Poison ivy is natural, but most patients would not go and rub it intentionally all over their body. Rattlesnakes are natural, but most patients would not try to be bitten by one. Obviously, just because something is natural does not mean it is effective and safe. It is true that many of the therapies used today were discovered in nature. These have been isolated, standardized, and purified. They have also been rigorously tested in controlled clinical trials to establish the effectiveness of the agent and its side effect profile.

Cancer patients are prime targets for unscrupulous individuals who attempt to gain financially from the misfortunes of others. Always remember, if a treatment sounds too good to be true, it may be a hoax. Here are some classic signs of a hoax that should place the cancer patient on the alert:

The treatment is a "secret" that only specific individuals can provide
Patients are told not to use conventional medical treatment
The treatment promises a cure for almost all cancers or medical conditions
The treatment is only promoted in the mass media such as the Internet, talk shows, and books instead of reputable scientific journals
The promoters claim they are persecuted by the medical establishment
Advertisements for the treatment claim to "cleanse the body of poisons and toxins"
The treatment will help the patient by "strengthening the immune system"
Testimonials and case reports are used to promote a specific treatment or product
Catch phrases such as "nontoxic", "no side effects" and "painless" are used
The promoters attack the medical community

If you are considering an alternative or complementary treatment be cautious and aware of any of the above claims. Always tell your doctor if you are considering any such treatment. Certain treatments may be helpful but others may interfere with your traditional treatments.